Skip to content

Stuff Your Easter Basket with Crafty, Silly, Fluffy, Fun Picks Under $25

Toys, books, stickers, crafts, stuffies, and more ways to build the ultimate Easter basket on a budget.

Margo Gothelf · 7 months ago

Thanks for checking out our product recommendations! Just a heads-up, Camp may make some money if you shop from any of the external links on this page. Pricing and availability may have changed since this page was published.

Looking for some fun toys, gadgets, and crafts to stuff your Easter basket with? No worries, we’ve got you covered. From puzzles to nail polish, you’ll be sure to fill up that basket faster than a bunny flicks his tail!

iScream Tie Dye Pastel Earbud Compact

These wireless headphones will instantly put your tween in the Easter spirit. The pastel-colored earbuds are Bluetooth friendly and quickly connect to all of their devices.

Ooly Double Dip Ice Cream Scented Markers

A small disclaimer before you open these markers: they might make you crave some ice cream! These double-ended washable markers not only come in crisp, bright colors but also smell like ice cream. With this set, you’ll be trading in your classic green for apple gelato green and blue for blueberry snowcone.

Klutz Puffy Sticker Kit

Stickers are always a good idea when it comes to an Easter basket. These stickers are even better because you get to design them yourself. Channel your inner artist and make one-of-a-kind designs. You’ll probably want to start off with some Easter stickers to get in the holiday spirit! 

Tiger Electronics Sonic Edition

This classic arcade game will transport you right back to the 90s. Join Sonic and Tails as they battle their way through six action-packed levels to defeat Mr. Egghead. Don’t worry, this Egghead guy has nothing to do with your Easter eggs.

Fashion Angels Glitter Everything Body & Hair Glitter Pink

Glitter is always a good idea! Spice up your Easter outfit with a little shine with this fashion glitter. Don’t worry, it's water-based and meant for your skin, unlike crafting glitter, so it won’t show up when you least expect it.

Open The Joy Rainbow Putty

This Easter, trade your slime in for some rainbow putty. This putty works just like slime but comes without the sticky mess. Not only is the putty fun to play with, but it also doubles as a fidget toy. That's an Easter basket find you can play with all year long!

Ooly Puffy Pens

Think these are just a regular set of pens? Think again. Magic Puffy Pens take any regular drawing and transform them into a 3D creation with the simple addition of a hairdryer. The set comes with six different colors for you to explore. Use the pastel colors and make an Easter-themed drawing on their first run out of the box.

Mindware Dig It Up! Dinosaur Eggs

Easter is all about finding those eggs, right? But these are no ordinary Easter eggs. Soak them in water to find out what is lurking inside: not candy, but a mini dinosaur!

Nailmatic Galaxy Bath Bomb

This galaxy-themed bath bomb will make bathtime the highlight of your day. Prepare a bath, drop this bath bomb in the tub, and watch the water transform into something from another galaxy. Your kids might be too preoccupied to realize they are actually getting clean at the same time.

Canticos Little Chickies Los Pollitos Reversible Book

This chunky book shares the heartwarming tale about a mother’s love for her baby chicks. The story, inspired by the nursery rhyme "Los pollitos dicen pío pío pío," can be read in both English and Spanish thanks to the nifty reversible storytelling pullout feature. It will be an excellent story to read right before you head to sleep after a full day of Easter fun.

L.O.L. Surprise! Remix Tots

Give your kids a little surprise of their own in their Easter baskets with these LOL Surprise Remix Tots. The miniature dolls each represent a different genre of music and even come with a song that plays music IRL. Some of the dolls even come with a Hair Flip surprise, giving them a whole new identity.

LEGO Make Your Own Movie

Quiet on the set — the Lego movie set that is. Take your Lego creations to the big screen and learn how to make your very own Lego movie with this stop-motion animation kit. The kit dives into all of the details and shows you the ropes for lighting, sound effects, and even different camera angles. Get ready to score an Oscar nomination next season!

GUND Fuzzy Chocolate Bear

This fluffy and plush chocolate brown teddy bear is about to become your new best friend. The 24-inch bear is the perfect size for a giant bear hug. One look at this beary cute face and you will quickly fall in love.

Star Wars Galaxy of Adventures Darth Vader

This year, let Darth Vader get in on the Easter celebration. Just because he's on the dark side, doesn’t mean he doesn’t want to indulge in Easter candy. Just make sure to keep an eye on his lightsaber!

Gnome Crayons Set

Why draw with regular crayons when you can draw with gnome crayons? These crayons come in six bright colors and will give you a good laugh every time you go to create a new drawing.

Workman Paint By Sticker Kids Zoo Animals Book

If you love paint by numbers, you’re sure to be a big fan of paint by stickers. It pretty much works the same way, without the mess of paint. Include this one in the Easter basket, but save it for a road trip or for an activity on the go. 

Thames & Kosmos Rainbow Gummy Candy Lab

Why chomp on store-bought jelly beans when you can make your own delicious Easter candy at home? Make tasty gummy rainbows, unicorns, and clouds in your choice of flavors, and your chocolate Easter bunny will have some new friends.